Monday, June 29, 2015

Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Super Keep Waterproof Black

Why did I bought the Kiss Me Heroine Make eyeliner again? My Smooth Liquid Eyeliner N Black is already more than two years old. It's the original eyeliner, stays for a long time, but not a waterproof type. Now that I have been using for two years, it's not as jet black as before. I find it hard to create eyeline and must swatch more than 3 times, especially for my left eye because it tends to be water-y when applying eyeliner. I bought Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Super Keep Black at Watsons (Yeah, Isehan is not only sold at Guardian, but also in Watsons) because it's the only pen liner there. I couldn't find my old N type and I didn't know much about Heavy Rotation.

Packaging is exactly the same as my N type, just different picture of Elizabeth. Elizabeth's picture is always funny in term of cute. As usual Japanese product, it came with plastic packaging. The pen tube's color is dark purple, almost black, with some glitters.

The ingredient list and how to do

It's purple, okay. The color is too dark to be captured at indoor lighting

This is the comparison color between Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner N and Super Keep pen:

The website says that Super Keep's brush tip is only 0.1mm, have 96.4% monitor's satisfaction, and easy to draw wing! Hmm, I would like to try this for sure.

And so, this is what the eyeliner looks like after applying:

On hand

On eyeline
Used : Rohto Hada Labo Gokujyun Lotion, Canmake Cover & Stretch Concealer UV, Rohto SUGAO Air Fit CC Cream Pink Bright Pure Natural, Coffret D'or Pink Blush, Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Super Keep, Canmake GOKUBUTO Mascara Black, Etude House Dear My Blooming Lips Talk OR204 (left), Revlon Colorburst Lacquer Balm Tease (right). I changed my lipstick because Etude is too oily and sink into lipline. The right picture is after 9 hours using the eyeliner.

I think the brush tip isn't as thin as my old N type. I feel it's heavier than N type pen too. I don't know about the latest N type, whether it has changed or not, but I like my N type brush tip better. For staying power, it's better than N type. When I rubbed N eyeliner, it came off easily. As for Super Keep, I must use at least water (with hard rubbing) or with Kracie Naive facewash to put it off. But the trial is only on my hand. What about on my eyeline? I tried wearing Super Keep when working. After lunch time (around 5 hours after applying), I felt that it was easy to put it off. I rubbed my eye crease with tissue a bit to remove excess sebum, but some of the eyeliner came off too on the sheet. But it's only the liner of my wing. So if I use it just on natural eyeline, it will have better staying, I guess. Thus, I still like my N type even though it's not waterproof.

Too bad Kiss Me Heroine Make pen / brush type eyeliner only came in black liner. I wish they would produce brown too. I guess I must search for different brand with brown eyeliner sold in here then, maybe Dolly Wink? I don't know, I don't have intention of trying Dolly Wink even though many people are satisfied about it. But I guess better trying then to make a judge. I'll find budget to purchase Dolly Wink eyeliner for sure.


  1. They make is in Brown colour now! (:

    1. I think the brown mascara version only available in Korea with pink tube. I saw a Japanese Youtuber (さあや Saaya channel) said she wish Japan will sell the brown version. So it doesn't get sold in Japan itself.